|
|
|
Members
of the School of Engineering's nuclear remediation team-Assistant
Professor Gene LeBeouf, Professor Frank Parker, Professor
James Clarke and Professor David Kosson-stand in the lab where
the long hours of analysis take place.
|
Most
people wouldn't want to spend much time on a remote island in Alaska
where the winds gust up to 150 miles per hour and where the rats
reign supreme.
There are even more compelling reasons
why Amchitka Island
will never become a popular tourist destination. Three nuclear bombs
were detonated under its surface from 1965-71, and its molten-glass
"shot cavities" took more than 20 years to cool back down
to normal temperature. And as if those occurrences wouldn't be a
sufficient deterrent, Greenpeace reported their (subsequently disputed)
finding in 1996 that radionuclides from these tests had been detected
in the terrestrial and freshwater environments.
Nonetheless, the Vanderbilt engineers
who specialize in nuclear remediation are eager to begin work there
next summer with their colleagues from the University of Alaska-Fairbanks.
The grim and forbidding island holds out the promise of revealing
valuable clues in the battle to reclaim or contain the land sacrificed
during the 1951-1992 Cold War arms race.
The School of Engineering Department
of Civil and Environmental Engineering has played an important
role in tackling the challenges presented by the world-wide legacy
of the nuclear age. From contaminated areas in Russia and the Czech
Republic to the major nuclear processing sites in the U.S., Vanderbilt
engineers have lent their expertise and conducted leading-edge research
into the complexities of environmental protection from nuclear and
other contaminants.
Chaired by Professor David S. Kosson,
who also heads up the national Remediation
Technology and Exposure
Assessment Task Group for the Consortium
for Risk Evaluation with Stakeholder Participation (CRESP),
the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering (CEE) remediation
specialists are helping find effective ways to clean up nuclear
weapons production facility waste sites and to design systems to
safely and efficiently contain wastes for thousands of years into
the future.
It's a daunting task.
Cold War, hot legacy
In the U.S. alone, more than 1,000 nuclear warheads were detonated
and almost 150 sites were used in nuclear weapons production. Of
those sites, portions of more than 100 are too severely contaminated
to be cleaned up sufficiently for unrestricted use and must be isolated
and contained, perhaps in some cases for tens of thousands of years.
In Russia, imprudent waste management resulted in widespread contamination,
including the Arctic Ocean; the Kara Sea; the Techa, Yenisey and
Tom Rivers and some 75 square miles of land in the Ural Mountains
that remain uninhabitable today after deliberate releases to the
Techa River in the late 1940s and early 1950s; a tank explosion
in 1957 and wind-driven contaminated Lake Karachai sediments.
"Approaching the problem of nuclear
remediation is like fighting an octopus," says Professor of
the Practice of Civil and Environmental Engineering James
H. Clarke. "You cut off one tentacle, and two more grow
in its place."
Like the other Vanderbilt environmental
engineers, Professor Clarke is stimulated by the complexities involved
in finding solutions. Awarded with a Department of Energy (DOE)
Corporate Award for his work at the Idaho National Engineering and
Environmental Laboratory to evaluate risk involved in using sonic
drilling to assess buried waste, Professor Clarke also helped write
the National
Research Council's 2000 report on long-term management of legacy
waste sites.
The report predicts a strong probability that institutional measures
will at some point fail to safely contain the wastes and notes that
scientific understanding of the complicated factors and forces involved
in contaminant behavior is inadequate. The report recommends additional
research as well as development of institutional management strategies
that take probable failure into account.
Professor Clarke and Frank
L. Parker, distinguished professor of environmental and water
resources engineering, emphasized those points in a recent presentation
to CRESP to gain funding for their research into risks and costs
predicted to be associated post-closure containment systems.
"We in the scientific and engineering community understand
that long-term containment approaches will probably fail,"
Professor Parker says. "But the systems that are being designed
currently are not taking this probable failure into sufficient account."
Focused
study, international implications
Professors Parker and Clarke will analyze the design for the Oak
Ridge secure landfill to determine what it will take to achieve
landfill security, given the probable risks and costs of the system.
They expect that their work will lead to more effective system designs
that can be used in other sites, as well, along with better post-closure
approaches and more realistic funding methods.
Also assisting the Oak Ridge Operation
is Eugene
J. LeBoeuf, assistant professor of civil and environmental engineering.
While a summer faculty research fellow at Oak Ridge National Laboratory,
Professor LeBoeuf studied ways to use dissolved natural organic
matter in in situ remediation to facilitate the process of removing
hazardous metals and radionuclides from groundwater flows.
"The presence of dissolved organic matter can assist electron
transfer, thus enhancing the reduction of many metal and radionuclide
species to less soluble forms, dropping them out of solution to
immobilize them in place," Professor LeBoeuf says.
He currently is employing advanced characterization techniques to
better understand how the physical and chemical structures of soil
and sediment organic materials react in the environment. He and
his research associates have applied for a patent for their new
design for a long-term vapor phase reactor vessel to study the process
of sorption/desorption processes of organic contaminants in unsaturated
conditions. This basic research, recently awarded a National Science
Foundation Faculty Early Career Development (CAREER) Award, will
lead to better understanding of how organic matter in soils and
sediments bind and sequester contaminants.
CRESP
role broadens remediation leadership
Like his colleagues, Professor LeBoeuf is excited about the School
of Engineering's important role in the nationwide remediation work
conducted by DOE-funded CRESP.
Professor Kosson, who joined Vanderbilt from Rutgers University
last spring, has led several projects at the Savannah River Site
(SRS) through CRESP activities. "CRESP initially focused on
remediation and waste-management activities at the Savannah River
Site and the Hanford Reservation in Washington," he says. "In
our second five-year phase, CRESP will expand its activities to
Oak Ridge Reservation, Rocky Flats in Colorado, Idaho National Engineering
Environmental Laboratory and Amchitka Island in Alaska."
Vanderbilt researchers have already been involved in CRESP SRS projects
to evaluate risk prioritization, to evaluate SRS background groundwater
quality through statistical methods and to assess cesium-137 mobility
in SRS surface soils.
In Amchitka, Professor Kosson expects to examine potential pathways
radionuclides could use to contaminate the Bering Sea and the North
Pacific Ocean. "The Bering Sea is a native Alaska population
fishing area and also accounts for a large fraction of the fish
supplies for the United States," he says. He and his associates
will evaluate potential movement of radionuclides from shot cavities
to the marine bodies and assess the risks to human beings and other
living things.
Global
expertise
Expert in assessing nuclear contaminant behavior in various waterways
is Professor Parker, the first environmental engineer certified
by eminence by the American Academy of Environmental Engineers.
"Professor Parker's expertise in
remediation is globally recognized," Professor Kosson says.
"He recently presented an overview of the world status on radioactive
waste to the Scientific Forum in the General Conference at the
United
Nation's International Atomic Energy Agency in Vienna in September."
Professor Parker has examined environmental
impact, risks and means of preventing and alleviating damage at
Russia's three reprocessing centers for spent nuclear fuel. One
project concerned Lake Karachai at Mayak in the Urals, the most
contaminated known area on earth. He and his associates determined
that the sediments in the Techa River posed a threat to the downstream
population and made recommendations to reduce the probability of
failure of the dams and to prevent a recurrence of the 1967 redistribution
of windborne radionuclides from Lake Karachai.
Professor Parker has also worked for
the Department of Energy to find ways to recycle or dispose of some
30 million tons of waste concrete from decommissioned military sites
around the country. The plan was predicted to save the U.S. up to
$1.3 billion.
Interdisciplinary
future
"Nuclear remediation is a field that requires the cooperative
and concerted efforts of people in many areas and absolutely demands
a multidisciplinary approach," Professor Kosson says. "The
School of Engineering is fortunate to include depth as well as breadth
of environmental expertise and to be able to draw from the wealth
of knowledge and experience within the several schools of Vanderbilt
University."
Professor Kosson is working with other
Vanderbilt schools to achieve the CRESP goal of enlisting cross-disciplinary
support in building consensus on long-term efforts to protect the
environment from the Cold War legacy.
"Maintaining appropriate systems
and awareness over a thousand or more years is an unprecedented
goal, but that's what will be needed if future generations are to
be protected from environmental contamination," he says. "We
will be working with people in fields like divinity to help us find
ways to pass down a tradition of effective stewardship of these
potentially hazardous areas far into the future."